Verify a futures signal record from contract to fill
Audit contract identity, roll events, original instructions, execution sequencing and account outcomes without substituting continuous charts.
Start with a deliverable contract identity
A futures ticker stem is not enough to reconstruct an order. Record the exchange, exact contract month, product variant, quantity, quote unit and session clock. A micro contract and a larger related contract can share a market direction while creating different monetary exposure. Keep the instrument specification effective during the review interval.
A continuous chart is a research representation, not an individually executable contract. If the history uses one, state its construction and roll policy. Do not assign a plotted continuous price to a broker fill unless the actual contract and execution observation separately support that claim.
Units and margin have official definitions
CME's tick education explains the relationship between minimum price movement and contract value. Its performance-bond FAQ explains margin as collateral within the clearing framework. These documents provide background; exact contract specifications and broker requirements still need their own current records. Margin is not a statement that the largest possible loss equals the amount posted.
Carry tick size, tick value, currency and quantity explicitly through the ledger. A percentage based on margin cannot be compared directly with a percentage based on account equity. Record which denominator the publisher actually uses before repeating a return headline.
A fictional stop-distance reconstruction
Assume a made-up contract worth $5 per tick and a twelve-tick planned stop distance. One contract has $60 of planned price-distance loss before charges. If the illustrative exit occurs sixteen ticks against entry, the price component is $80; adding $6 of total assumed charges gives $86.
Neither scenario supplies a maximum loss guarantee or a real exchange specification. The example shows why intended stop distance, observed fill and net outcome need separate fields. Record actual entry and exit quantities as well as prices, because incomplete fills change both exposure and the meaning of an average price.
Retain the roll as a separate event
Closing one contract and entering another produces its own orders, costs and possible basis difference. Keep the old and new contract identifiers with their acknowledgements. A continuous-series adjustment can change a chart level without producing a gain or loss that an account actually realised.
If a signal spans a roll boundary, request the publisher's conversion and exit policy as originally stated. Do not choose the contract retrospectively based on which path best meets the target. Missing individual-contract observations limit the execution reconstruction even when a continuous-series research exercise can still be completed honestly.
Reconcile message timing and outcomes
Preserve original entry instructions, amendments, expiry and the subscriber receipt time. Finer observations may resolve competing stop and target touches; a single bar that crosses both levels cannot establish their order. Apply the declared ambiguity convention and keep unresolved cases visible. An ideal chart touch does not demonstrate a fill.
Keep cancellations, missed entries, closed losses and open positions in the eligible population. Partial target updates need quantity weighting rather than extra independent wins. Distinguish a publisher call result from a source account and from your actual account statement, including financing or fees where the product and broker impose them.
State which layer was verified
A content receipt can support a timing claim for particular bytes, but it does not establish history completeness or execution. A broker acknowledgement identifies an order, but its acceptance is not proof of the final fill. An account calculation requires cash flows and open exposure under a disclosed convention.
Report verified fields, unavailable records and ambiguous cases alongside any summary. No independent audit engagement or subscriber-return forecast follows from completing this checklist. The strongest deliverable is a contract-level reconciliation that another reviewer can repeat, with continuous research references clearly separated from actual order evidence.

Evidence handoff
| Check | Record | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Contract | Dated specification and month | Continuous chart is not an order identity |
| Instruction | Original call and amendment events | No favourable sequence guessed from one bar |
| Execution | Fills, quantities and costs | Stop distance is not a guaranteed loss ceiling |
Column definitions: call_id, exchange, contract_month, product_variant, tick_size, tick_value, currency, published_at, received_at, order_id, actual_quantity, fill_price, roll_event_id, exit_fill, charges, outcome_state.
No example trade or user record is stored in the download. Keep credentials and personal account identifiers out of shared copies.
Population and timing at the same boundary
A fictional sample contains ten original ideas, two amendments and three duplicate deliveries. Its signal population is still ten, not fifteen. If four ideas lack account fills, their hypothetical publisher outcomes must remain separate from the six documented account cases. Excluding the four without explaining their state would change the comparison population.
Freeze the original definition before evaluating outcomes, and retain research entry conventions rather than substituting guessed broker prices. The new replay, identity and partial-fill chapters deepen those checks. Software correctness tests prove the publication's controls work; they do not authenticate a provider or become independent strategy-validation observations.